· 1 year ago

Is conscious travel a form of elitism?

13 Comments
Share
Recommend this?

Comments

Sustainability in tourism often means higher costs, limited accessibility, etc.

Is it only for the elite?

I've been asked this question a lot, so I'm curious to hear your thoughts!

I'm a new member in this amazing community. Born and raised in Italy, I've been living in the US for the past 12 years. I'm starting a lifestyle brand for the conscious traveler... let's connect!

1 year ago (edited)
Ian
Founder, Travel Massive

Hi Ricardo, welcome to the community and great question.

A quick Google for “Conscious Travel” and there’s dozens of results with a few variations on its definition.

Now I have to preface my response with my own view that I think terms like “conscious” and “transformative” travel are buzzwords. But people have built entire businesses on these themes of travel, so maybe I’m wrong. I just humbly believe that travel can be great, sustainable, empathetic, powerful, and life changing without needing to say so. To me, these things are kinda obvious.

Whether this kind of travel is considered elite probably depends on who claims ownership of the term. Is someone who paid $4,000 for a “conscious travel” group tour to Mexico more entitled as a planet-saver than say, someone who bought a tent for $200 at Cosco and went hiking for a weekend? I’m making this up, but you get my drift.

The more introspective we become in our travels (and the more buzzwords appear), the more I believe that travel is ultimately about going from A to B and what you make of it in between.

If it floats your boat to call it conscious travel, and you’re not misleading anyone in the process, then go for it!

1 year ago
Founder, Made to Wander

I don't think it needs to be only for the elite. It's a bit like fine wine in a way. Not everybody can afford Lafite or DRC but you can still drink something that gives just as much joy. Travel is no different.

1 year ago
Founder, Business Development, Painted Circle

Ciao Riccardo! This is an important question for all of us in travel to ask ourselves. If our goal is to make travel more sustainable, regenerative, more "any of Ian's buzzwords here ;)" then we have to be able to welcome all types of travelers into those efforts. Sustainable places and experiences can not be just for some - they must be for all.

There is a great deal of education that could happen in our industry. It's possible that many travelers would make better choices if they knew more of the behind-the-scenes and the impact of what they are purchasing. Not everyone is going to want to travel sustainably all the time, but I'm optimistic that with more options coming online, we can make sustainable travel less about being trendy and more about being desirable and more fulfilling. There are also more diverse voices being heard in the travel space, and we all need to help support expanding the narrative from just one perspective to many - all part of the process of getting less buzzwordy and more authentic.

Ricardo - feel free to connect as I'm curious about what you are building!

1 year ago
Chief Impact Officer, Tourism Cares

Hi Ricardo. In my experience sustainable travel does not mean more costs. I often hear that it means higher costs or limited accessibility and then the next day I hear its only for the budget traveler. Sustainable travel is about not harming the environment, local cultures or communities. Its about makings sure more money stays in the destination (very little does). Sustainable travel is using local transportation, using locally owned hotels, restaurants, working with local artisans, contributing to impact organizations whenever possible, and behaving in a way you would want visitors to your own home to behave. And every travel business should be moving toward incorporating sustainable practices into their business models. Travel businesses should be using these principals as a management tool and not a marketing tool and then we will all be able to travel sustainably not matter where or who we travel with.

1 year ago
Head Chef, Travelfish Pty Ltd

Strong disagree on equating sustainable tourism with higher costs and agree with Ian re the industry embracing new buzzwords more often than I buy new flip flops. Think one of the big issues in this is there is an army of consultants who, dare I say, sustain themselves by making a living out of telling anyone that will pay to listen that it the high-end sustainability play is the only play in town.

Case in point, I Googled conscious travel, as I couldn’t remember what it was (I confuse it a lot with meaningful tourism—another buzz word) and the second result was some start up that would charge me 1,200 quid to teach me all about it. LOL no—though I guess I did need to Google it.

I interviewed the Chief Purpose Officer for a major mid- to upper-end tour company the other day, they’re busy carbon counting for all their operations to affix a carbon value to each tour. I asked how they’re treating small businesses (ie joints backpackers use) that can’t afford to get on the greenwashing certification train vs the lux joints that can, and she said “we usually consider homestays as responsible per se.”

To my mind, that says a lot.

1 year ago

That's an excellent point and part of the reason why I think that the focus should be on educating the public instead. Thanks for sharing!

1 year ago

Thanks for the insights! I see many great points here. I’d like to share my point of view and keep the conversation going. With so many people traveling all over the world, I think it’s crucial to raise awareness about the often-overlooked side effects of tourism.

I don’t believe that encouraging to travel consciously is a form of elitism, but many people imagine it to be.
Just like healthy eating is often considered more expensive, but it doesn’t have to be. It just requires different choices and usually more work. Similarly, anyone can travel in a way that respects the environment and the local community. On any budget. But doing so will require some flexibility and effort. It will require more researching, planning, and picking certain options over others. It may require saying no at times and discovering alternatives. And this is a good thing, because we force ourselves to look beyond the mainstream, so we are more likely to have authentic experiences and create connections.

Our choices, even the small ones, matter. And they add up. This is why awareness and education are so important, like Charles said. Simply thinking about where your money goes and focusing on directing it to the local community is a powerful tool that any traveler can use regardless of how deep his/her pockets are. As Paula mentioned, too much of our spending goes elsewhere.

I’m glad that several of you agree with Ian on conscious tourism being a buzzword. Because it means that to you and me it represents the standard way to travel. It’s simply tourism. I think that this terminology helps distinguish it from other types of tourism that are, instead, disruptive. This distinction (and labeling) is helpful when we must educate the public, in my opinion.

Thanks again for all the upvotes and comments!

1 year ago

Great question Riccardo, and one I think needs more attention. If we look at travel and tourism pragmatically, no matter how you engage in it tourism by nature is exploitative. Somewhere in the tourism value chain there will be a imbalance in resources in which something loses out. Whether that's the environment, the socio-cultural aspects and the community, or the economic aspects - in my experience it's very difficult to find a travel experience that is able to positively contribute to all three pillars.

Couple that with the incredible job that marketing professionals have done to greenwash the industry in recent years and you've got the perfect breeding ground for elitism to take hold. But that doesn't necessarily mean this form of responsible or sustainable tourism experience has to only be for the elite. It also matters how you would define "elite". I think the most important thing is something you've already pointed out: education. And the subsequent access to resources that allow both the supply and demand side of tourism to better self-regulate and internally understand what a "sustainable tourism" experience means to them.

At the end of the day collaboration is key. Liburd and Edwards have a great publication named Collaboration for Sustainable Tourism Development that touches on these key issues if you're ever curious about the academic perspective! I'm curious how you plan to enact sustainable sourcing of travel products on Overview Effect! Looking forward to your launch.

1 year ago

Great answer and thanks for the suggestion! I'll take a look at the publication.
Sustainable sourcing will occur in two ways: materials (recycled, vegan, and that tread lightly) and manufacturing (employment in disadvantaged communities at fair pay and conditions). I'll keep you posted!

1 year ago
Photo Journalist, RK Journeyman

I use the term thoughtful travel for both the folks traveling and those receiving them as guests in their community. I think the travel world is moving away from the nostalgic, dreamy, big bus, all inclusive tourism to a more considerate approach to the places we visit. New travelers have a number of real opportunities to dispell their fears and travel with small groups of kindred spirits. It's important for us to show them the options for more authentic travel experiences. I encourage those looking at travel options to avoid things like- " Off the Beaten Path ", "50 bucket list places you must see" or a favorite-" Charming Small Town". "2023 popular destinations." The list goes on. If there is a city with an ad with a fancy car on a windy backroad, you know there are traffic jams there to be experienced. Plan smart. Find local guides and bloggers.

1 year ago (edited)

I agree, the needs are changing and planning is an important tool in regards

1 year ago

I also don't believe it's for the elite. For example, I traveled to the Peruvian Amazon and stayed at this amazing lodge over the summer, and they are eco-friendly and doing away with plastic bottles, etc. Everyone pays the same price, including solo travelers. So I guess this question can be debated and looked at from both sides. I think more places are trying to encourage sustainability, but I don't think only the elite can afford this type of travel. I'm not sure if I'm answering this question!

1 year ago
👋 Welcome to the Travel Massive community!
Profile picture Profile picture Profile picture Profile picture Profile picture Profile picture + 406 others joined this month

Contributors

About this Discussion
Post icon

Is conscious travel a form of elitism?

Is conscious travel a form of elitism? was posted by Riccardo in Discussion , Sustainability , Responsible Travel . Updated on Nov 23, 2022 (1 year ago). Is conscious travel a form of elitism? is not rated yet.
19 Upvotes